Culture Health & Illness Theme Four
- In Medicine and Medical Anthropology, a culture-specific syndrome or culture-bound syndrome
is a combination of psychiatric and somatic symptoms that are
considered to be a recognisable disease only within a specific society
or culture
- Refers to Mental Illness, as described in non Western Societies
- It is said to be ''bound'' to a particular culture
- Cultural interpretations of metal disorders & the meanings they attach to them
ARE CULTURAL BOUND SYNDROME UNIQUIE TO A PARTICULAR CULTURE OR ARE THEY UNIVERSAL
IF THEY ARE UNIVERSAL IS IT SIMPLY THE WAY PATHOLOGY IS EXPRESSED & INTERPRETED THAT IS DIFFERENT
If we look at:
- Schizophrenia
- Paranoia
- Multiple Personality
- Stress Response
- Anorexia Nervosa
- Bulimia
Answer is Yes they are universal as Diseases BUT how they are interpreted are different
Theoretical Positions to c.b.s
1. Exclusionist Position
- Are believed to be different & unique
- Can not be classified to western diseases
- Viewed as an Illness not a Disease
- Cultural belief attached to them
2. Inclusionist Position
- Both Nature & nurturer (nature-culture continuum)
- Each aspects is shaped by the other
- No Disease is unique to a particular culture
- All Diseases have nature & nurturer components attached to them
3. Multiaspect- inclusionist
- All diseases are equal
- Have Culture, Biology & Psychology attached to them
- All diseases around the world are C.B Illnesses
- Therefore this word C.B.S does not exist
Case Studies
Arctic Hysteria
- First documented in the Eskimo Society in the 19th century (1892)
- Found in the Arctic (Northern Greenland)
- Considered to be a mental illness
- Occurred during the dark winter months
- Eskimos lived in small structures
- Men and women used to come out of there homes, take of their clothes
- Run and jump in the snow and icy water
- In a fit of rage, run screaming and shouting
- People from the Society goes out looking for them and bring them back before they die of Hyperthermia
- Westerners called this Artic Hysteria
- Interpretation
- Winter last 6 months (confirmed to small space)
- Frustration is high
- Feeling Cluster phobic- need get out
- Stress levels are high
- Brake free
- Stress Response
Grisi Siknis
- Misko Indians in Central America,
- Documented 100 years ago (found be highly contagious)
- It affects mostly young women (starting at age 15 leading up to 60) but men can get it as well
- Go into hysterical fit
- They say that the devil calls to them; it hits them and even has sex with them
- The person need to be subdued
- They are tied down by roped and gagged, taken back to the village
- They are taken to the traditional healer for treatment
- With time the sickness goes away
- It may happen more than once to a person Illness sequence
- Shape headache and loss of appetite
- Falls down in a state of fit
- Thereafter wakes up and starts running
- While running pick up things start throwing them
- Screaming and curing at people, using strange words
- They say person is possessed
- She calls name of a particular boy
- This young man is expected to go bring back her back
- She gets tied up to calm down
- Healer comes in and treats her with stream that contain traditional herbs, which she needs to inhale in 4 directions
- This suppose to calm her down
- Many young girls experience this illness
- This can be contagious
- If a girl is experiencing this, mothers bring their daughters in
the home and locked them up, in fear of their daughters getting it
- Sometimes it happens at big gathers were many girls collapse and act out
- People say:
- G.S is caused by the devil (combination of Christian & Indian Belief)
- Swanta in Miskito culture is a short man, lives in the forest, does evil things
- Liwa (mermaid) lives in water and seduces men, she attracts
widowers & single men. If they sleep with her they have disable
children & get sicknesses
- Swanta & Liwa are demons
- We see the Christian & Naïve beliefs are combined (belief in Sacrilege)
- Rape of a girl caused by Swanta & Liwa cause of disease
- Seen in Christian terms as God casting out the fallen angle (the
devil), can to earth in the forest they known as Swanta & Liwa
- Interpretations
- G.S is a patterned stress response
- Need look at historical factors
- Miskito Indians lived on the coastlands & had contact with Christian missionaries
- They outlawed the belief systems of the Miskito Indians
- Forced to go into the cash economy to work to pay taxes
- This brought added stress
- They used Grisi Siknis TO ACT OUT AGAINST THE COLONIAL RULE. To vent their frustration
- With women, they are expected to care for the children & take
care of the household & take abuse from their husbands, GENDER
OPPRESSION
- Women can't take it anymore & need to release their anger & depression, they ACT OUT
- Get attention from the community they use G.S as an excuse. Called Grisis Mwaia (attention seeking)
- Young girls, they are expected be modest, dutiful, obedient & must not go out alone
- Relationship before marriage is forbidden, marriage is arranged
- Frustrated with this they act out, and call boy's name (her boyfriend) so they can be alone
- They have sex with their boyfriends & say they were raped by Swanta
- People are non judgmental, they do not blame the person but the illness, behaviour is justified
- Conclusion
- People have different ways of handling stress
- C.B.S need to understood within the historical context
- G.S is a stress response and a brake away from the norm of the society
Anorexia Nervosa
- Western type of c.b.s= self starvation
- Occurs mainly among young girls/women: also can affect boys/men
- It is characterized by (symptoms)
- Fear of gaining weight
- Refusal to maintain optimal body weight
- Think they are fat
- Hence it is Psychological
- Females miss 3/4 menstrual cycle
- Hyperactive
- It is a Psychological disease
- Distorted view of their bodies
- This condition is brought upon by emotional disorders that lead a
person to worry/get anxious about their physical appearance and body
image
CAUSED BY WHAT WE CALL TODAY CULTURAL TRANSCRIPTS
- We are living a the technological era, consumed by media
- Media projects beauty as people with perfect bodies
- It was found in many western societies' girls as young as 7 are afraid of getting fat
- Developed FAT phobia
- People are concerned what the media projects
- High achievers in families are supposed to a certain way, can be family pressure to b the perfect person
- Fatness is no longer valued
- Culture starting to change call this Cultural Change Syndrome
- As a result of urbanization/westernization
- Advancement in technology
- Direct influence of the media
- Some Religions (in particular eastern religions) promote Anorexia
- Women are required to undertake long fasts
- By fasting it is believed one obtains higher spirituality, this helps their husbands & children progress
- At first it was a western disease, through globalization it as now spread across the world
- Hence it is no longer culture bound